[www.youtube.com]

This was very interesting. It should be titled, "Raw Food Gurus: Before the Great Schism"

Thanks for posting.

He had great points but he was wrong on juicing.
Fiber is overrated.

david wolfe shouldve stayed at that weight. he looks good. was he in his fruitarian phase in 2000?

Panchito,

Thanks again for posting another great Video from Antisthenez. Another great Video they uploaded just recently was a speech given by Dr. Russell Trall back in 1862 and is included in “Toxemia Explained” by Dr. John Tilden and republished by T. C. Fry. This prompted me to revisit this speech, which I read over 20 years ago and I ended up creating a file on Typhoid Fever, which I will start a new Thread so that I can share my File Preview.

RawPracticalist,

I agree with you 1000% about Doug’s twisted views towards Juicing. I agree that we should NEVER drink Fruit Juice on an ongoing basis, but Vegetable Juices and Juice Fasting/Feasting is a whole different story. My guess is that Juice Fasting/Feasting threatens Doug and his Water Fasting Retreats because you don’t need to be supervised on a Juice Fast/Feast in the same way one needs to be supervised on a Water Fast.

Peace and Love..........John

John Rose Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
My guess is that Juice
> Fasting/Feasting threatens Doug and his Water
> Fasting Retreats because you don’t need to be
> supervised on a Juice Fast/Feast in the same way
> one needs to be supervised on a Water Fast.
>
> Peace and Love..........John

how can you even compare the two ..its like comparing apples to .. umm water ..
one can contain allsorts of different nutrients ..the other an entirely different set of nutrients .. thats the point

water is water .. juice is juice .. 2 entirely different things

...Jodi, the banana eating buddhist

<<<how can you even compare the two>>>

Are you saying that you cannot compare Water Fasting to Juice Fasting?

Are you saying there there is nothing in common between these two?

Am I missing something?

yea the word "fasting" they have in common lol

...Jodi, the banana eating buddhist

Have you ever heard of the Empty Bowel Theory?

Yes John but please enlighten me to your version of it

and if you could keep the post less then 12 inches of measurable length that would be great too (and easier to read)

...Jodi, the banana eating buddhist

Since you want me to keep it short, tell me your version first.

this isn't a game of ping pong john. You asked me a question i responded now I've asked you , you answer

...Jodi, the banana eating buddhist